AN ERROR IN THE CZECH EDITION OF MASARYK-RADLOV CORRESPONDENCE

  • Жозеф Мурал ниверситет Яна Евангелиста Пуркине в Усти-над-Лабем
Ключевые слова: Т. Г. Масарик, Э. Л. Радлов, масариковедение, Д. Юм, Я.Опат, Е.Ф.Фирсов

Аннотация

In the Czech edition of T. G. Masaryk’s corre-spondence with E. L. Radlov published in 2015, the editors misidentify a book, referred to in the letters, and as a consequence chronologi-cally misplace one letter preserved without dating. They repeat and magnify) the error committed already by their Russian colleague E. F. Firsov in his book “Т. Г. Масарик и рос-сийская интеллектуальная среда” 2005). They all fail to take into account Masaryk’s translation of David Hume’s second “Enquiry” into German 1883), to which Radlov’s expres-sions such as “your Hume”, “Hume” and “your Hume translation” refer in the relevant letters. Instead, the editors assert that Radlov first ex-pects and then receives Masaryk’s Prague inau-gural lecture on Hume and the calculus of probabilities “Počet pravděpodobnosti a Hu-mova skepse”, 1883), and next expects Ma-saryk’s shortened and modified German version of it “Dav. Humes Skepsis und die Wahr-scheinlichkeitsrechnung”, 1884). This is rather significant also as an indication of the rather widespread ignorance of Masaryk’s translation of Hume which could have been, for a while, his internationally best known work) among the Czech Masaryk scholars: thus Jaroslav Opat the founding director of the new Masaryk In-stitute of the Czech Academy of Sciences) in his 470-pages-long monograph on Masaryk’s philosophy and politics in 1882–1893 first con-siders it Masaryk’s own work “Eine Unter-suchung über die Prinzipen der Moral von David Hume”, 1883) and then ignores it com-pletely.

Литература

Doubek, V., Květina, J. (eds.), Korespondence T. G. Masaryk – Slované: Poláci, Rusové a Ukrajinci [Correspondence of T. G. Masaryk and Slavs: Poles, Russians and Ukrainians], vol. 1, Prague: Masarykův ústav AV ČR, 2015.

Firsov, Ye.F., Dva myslitelya – dva druga: Tomash Masarik i Ernest Radlov v perepiske (konets XIX – nachalo XX veka) [Two thinkers – two friends: Tomas Ma-saryk and Ernest Radlov in correspondence (late 19 – early 20 centuries)], URL: www.mecenat-and-world.ru/25-28/masarik.htm.

Firsov, Ye.F., T.G. Masarik i rossiyskaya intellektual'naya sreda (po arkhivam Che-khii i Rossii). Ch. 1: Tomash Masarik i Ernest Radlov v nauchnoy i druzheskoy perepiske [Masaryk and the Russian intellectual environment (on the archives of the Czech Republic and Russia). Part 1: Tomas Masaryk and Ernest Radlov in sci-entific and friendly correspondence], Moscow: Poligrafizdat, 2005.

Hume, D., Eine Untersuchung über die Prinzipien der Moral [An enquiry concern-ing the principles of morals], translated by T. G. Masaryk, Wien: Carl Konegen, 1883.

Masaryk, T.G., Das Selbstmord als soziale Massenerscheinung der modernen Zivi-lisation [Suicide as a social mass phenomenon of modern civilization], Wien: Carl Konegen, 1881.

Masaryk, T.G., Dav. Hume’s Skepsis und die Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung: ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Logik und Philosophie [Dav. Hume's skepticism and the probability calculus: a contribution to the history of logic and philosophy], Wien: Carl Konegen, 1884.

Masaryk, T.G., Počet pravděpodobnosti a Humova skepse: historický úvod v theo-rii indukce [The calculus of probabilities and Hume’s scepticism: a historical intro-duction into theory of induction], Prague: J. Otto, 1883.

Moural, J., Omyl ve vydání Masarykovy korespondence [A mistake in the publica-tion of Masaryk's correspondence], in Filosofický časopis [Philosophical journal], 2018, no. 66.

Moural, J., The reception of David Hume in Czech thought, in Jones, P. (ed.), The Reception of David Hume in Europe, London, New York: Thoemmes Continuum, 2005.

Opat, J., Filozof a politik T. G. Masaryk, 1882–1893 [Philosopher and politician T. G. Masaryk, 1882–1893], Prague: Melantrich, 1990.

Pochman, J., A selected bibliography of the most significant works by T. G. Masa-ryk, in Czech Sociological Review, 1995, no. 3.

Polák, S., T. G. Masaryk: Za ideálem a pravdou, vol. 1 (1850–1882) [T. G. Masa-ryk: For the sake of the ideal and truth, vol. 1 (1850–1882)], Prague: Masaryk insti-tute AS ChR, 2000.

Schuhmann, K., Husserl and Masaryk, in Novák, J. (ed.), On Masaryk: Texts in English and German, Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1988.

Schuhmann, K., Husserl-Chronik: Denk- und Lebensweg Edmund Husserls [Husserl chronicle: Thought and life of Edmund Husserl], The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1977.

Опубликован
2018-06-30
Как цитировать
Мурал, Ж. (2018). AN ERROR IN THE CZECH EDITION OF MASARYK-RADLOV CORRESPONDENCE . Философский полилог, (1), 143-148. извлечено от http://polylogue.jourssa.ru/index.php/polylogue/article/view/19
Выпуск
Раздел
ПОЛЕМИКА