Quiet power of thinking (reflections on the fate of the historian of philosophy in the modern world)

  • Tatiana Suhodub The cetre of the humanities of the Hational academy of sciences of the Ukraine
Keywords: G. E. Alyaev, historian of philosophy, history of Russian philosophy, specificity of historical and philosophical knowledge, philosophical community

Abstract

The article discusses the creative way of Gennadiy Alyaev in the context of the history of philosophy, its tasks and specifics. Bibliography as a visible result of the philosopher’s creative activity can be explained not only in terms of the topics and problems studied, but also by taking into account his biography and socio-cultural realities of life. Therefore, region study is used as the methodology which involves studying “memory places”, the connection of “place”, “time” and “thought” of the philosopher, using verbal and non-verbal sources in the analysis. The history of philosophy is understood, firstly, as the history of philosophies, which are a polyphony of unique intellectual and ideological positions that recreate the work of individuals, secondly, as the activity of philosophical communities, helping to discover talents and to form a philosophical worldview. In the first aspect the philosophical and scientific work of G. E. Alyaev is aimed at studying the philosophy of S. L. Frank – the thinker who uses both ethical and philosophical-anthro­po­lo­gi­cal discourses in order to understand the spiritual foundations of social being and create intellectual conditions for the moralization of social and political relations. The second aspect of the activity of the historian of philosophy is as important as the first one because it implies the historian of philosopher being responsible for the Others and for the actuality of Philosophy, that is, for creating the proper philosophical culture of people.

References

Alyaev, G.E. Nikolay Berdyaev i teoriya gosudarstva [Nikolay Berdyaev and state theory], in Collegium, 2001, No. 11.

Alyaev, G.E. Semyon Frank [Semyon Frank], St. Petersburg: Nauka, 2017.

Alyaev, G.E., Voznyak, V.S., Gromov, M.N., and others. Genezis i puti razvitiya russkoy i ukrainskoy filosofskoy mysli – Henezys i shlyakhy rozvytku rosiys'koyi ta ukrayins'koyi filosofs'koyi dumky [Genesis and the ways of development of Russian and Ukrainian philosophical thought], eds. G. E. Alyaev, N. A. Kutsenko, T. D. Su¬kho¬¬dub, Poltava: ASMI, 2013.

Alyaev, G.E., Emelyanov, B.V., Mozgovaya, N.G., Sukhodub, T.D. O religioznykh filosofakh Rossii i Ukrainy: personalisticheskie ocherki [About religious philo¬sophers of Russia and Ukraine: personalistic essays], Poltava: ASMI, 2010.

Alyaev, G.E., Rezvykh, T.N. “Problema teoditsei – istochnik russkogo revo¬lyu¬tsi¬on¬no¬go sotsializma”. Parizhskiy doklad Semyona Franka 1938 goda [“The problem of theodicy is a source of Russian revolutionary socialism”. Semyon Frank’s speech in Paris, 1938], in Vestnik Russkoy khristianskoy gumanitarnoy Akademii [Bulletin of the Russian Christian Academy of the Humanities], 2018, No. 2, vol. 19.

Alyaev, G.E., Rezvykh, T.N. S. L. Frank i N. A. Berdyaev: epizody emigratsii [S. L. Frank and N. A. Berdyaev: episodes of their emigration], in “Velikiy kievlyanin” Nikolay Berdyaev [“The great Kiev citizen” Nikolay Berdyaev], eds. M. Yu. Savelyeva, T. D. Sukhodub, G. E. Alyaev. Kiev: Dmitry Burago Publishing House, 2018.

Alyaеv, G. Bіlya vytokіv radyans'koyi fіlosofіyi. Bogdanov contra Lenіn: nauka proty vіry? [Near the origins of Soviet philosophy. Bogdanov contra Lenin: science against faith?], in Fіlosofs'ka dumka [Philosophical thought], 2009, No. 3.

Alyaеv, G.Е. Ontologіya і fenomenologіya nezbagnennogo: S. L. Frank u fіlo¬sof¬s'ko¬mu diskursі ХХ storіchchya: avtoref. dis. na zdobuttya naukovogo stupenya doktora fіlos. nauk: spets. 09.00.05 “Іstorіya fіlosofіyi” [Ontology and pheno¬me¬no¬lo¬gy of the incomprehensible: S. L. Frank in the philosophical discourse of the 20th century: Author’s abstract of the dissertation for the Doctor of Sciences in Philosophy degree, speciality 09.00.05 “History of Philosophy”], Kiev, 2003.

Alyaеv, G.Е. Ukrayins'ka і rosіys'ka fіlosofіyi: chynnyky yednannya chy roz¬kho¬d¬zhen¬nya [Ukrainian and Russian philosophies: the factors of unity or con¬flict?], in Іstorіya fіlosofіyi yak shkola dumky. Zbіrnyk na poshanu profesora Stepana Mykhaylovycha Voznyaka (do 85-rіchchya z dnya narodzhennya) [The history of philosophy as a school of thought. Collection of works in honor of Professor Stepan Mikhailovich Woznyak (to the 85th anniversary of his birth)] / Eds. V. K. Larіonova, O. B. Gutsulyak, Ivano-Frankivsk: Publishing House of Precarpathian National University named after Vasyl Stefanyk, 2013.

Alyaev, G.E. Fіlosofs'kyy unіversum S. L. Franka. Personalіstychna metafіzyka vseyednostі v goryzontakh novoyi ontologіyi XX stolіttya [Philosophical universe of S. L. Frank. The personalistic metaphysics of all-unity in the horizons of the new ontology of the 20th century], Kiev: PARAPAN, 2002.

Grazhdanin mira Maksimilian Voloshin [Citizen of the world Maksimilian Voloshin], eds. M. Yu. Savelyeva, G. E. Alyaev, T. D. Sukhodub, Kiev: Dmitry Bura¬go Publishing House, 2017.

“Kul'turnoe pogranichye” L'va Shestova [Lev Shestov’s “cultural frontier”], eds. G. E. Alyaev, M. Yu. Savelyeva, T. D. Sukhodub, Kiev: Dmitry Burago Publishing House, 2016.

Natsional'naya stikhiya tvorchestva: vremya i transgressiya: Sbornik statey [The national essence of creativity: time and transgression: Collection of articles], eds. G. E. Alyaev, O. D. Masloboeva, St. Petersburg: SPbSEU Publishinf House, 2017.

Tvorchestvo kak natsional'naya stikhiya: opyt Rossii i Ukrainy: Sbornik statey [Creati¬vity as the national character: the experience of Russia and Ukraine: Col¬lec¬tion of articles], eds. G. E. Alyaev, O. D. Masloboeva. St. Petersburg: SPbSEU Publishinf House, 2015.

Tvorchestvo kak natsional'naya stikhiya: media i sotsial'naya aktivnost': Sbornik statey [Creativity as the national character: media and social activity: Collection of articles], eds. G. E. Alyaev, O. D. Masloboeva, St. Petersburg: SPbSEU Publishinf House, 2018.

Ukrainskiy zhurnal russkoy filosofii. Vestnik Obshchestva russkoy filosofii pri Uk¬ra¬inskom filosofskom fonde [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so-phi¬cal foundation], No. 2: Ge¬roizm i podvizhnichestvo. Tvorchestvo S. N. Bulgakova v sovremennom dis¬kur¬se (k 130-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya S. N. Bulgakova) [Heroism and asceti¬cism. The works of S. N. Bulgakov in the modern discourse (to the 130th anniversary of the birth of S. N. Bulgakov)], Kiev: Raduga, 2005.

Ukrainskiy zhurnal russkoy filosofii. Vestnik Obshchestva russkoy filosofii pri Uk¬ra¬inskom filosofskom fonde [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so-phi¬cal foundation], No. 4: Poeziya v filosofii – filosofiya v poezii (k 170-letnemu yubileyu polnogo izdaniya ro¬ma-na v stikhakh A. S. Pushkina “Evgeniy Onegin” [Poetry in philosophy – phi¬lo¬sophy in poetry (to the 170th anniversary of the full edition of the novel in verses by A. S. Pushkin “Evgeniy Onegin”], Kiev: Kievskaya Rus, 2010.

Ukrainskiy zhurnal russkoy filosofii. Vestnik Obshchestva russkoy filosofii pri Uk¬ra¬inskom filosofskom fonde [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so-phi¬cal foundation], No. 5–6: F. M. Dostoevskiy i kanun tretyego tysyacheletiya. Stanovlenie i razvitie klassicheskoy russkoy filosofskoy traditsii: ot I. V. Kireevskogo do D. L. Andreeva [F. M. Dostoevsky and the eve of the third millennium. Formation and development of the classical Russian philosophical tradition: from I. V. Kireevsky to D. L. Andreev], eds. G. Alyaev, T. Sukhodub, Kiev: Kievskaya Rus, 2010.

Ukrainskiy zhurnal russkoy filosofii. Vestnik Obshchestva russkoy filosofii pri Uk¬ra¬inskom filosofskom fonde [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so-phi¬cal foundation], No. 8: Fenomen filosofskoy kritiki v kul'ture rossiyskogo Serebryanogo veka (k 100-letiyu vykhoda sbornika statey o russkoy intelligentsii “Vekhi” [The phenomenon of philosophical criticism in the culture of the Russian Silver Age (to the 100th anniversary of the publication of the collection of articles about the Russian intelligentsia “Vekhi”], eds. G. Alyaev, T. Sukhodub, Poltava: ASMI, 2009.

Ukrainskiy zhurnal russkoy filosofii. Vestnik Obshchestva russkoy filosofii pri Uk¬ra¬inskom filosofskom fonde [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so-phi¬cal foundation], No. 9: N. V. Gogol': dukhovnoe izmerenie zhizni i tvorchestva (k 200-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya) [N. V. Gogol: the spiritual view on life and creative work (to the 200th anniversary of his birth)], eds. G. Alyaev, T. Sukhodub, Poltava: ASMI, 2010.

Ukrainskiy zhurnal russkoy filosofii. Vestnik Obshchestva russkoy filosofii pri Uk¬ra¬inskom filosofskom fonde [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so-phi¬cal foundation], No. 10: Russkaya filosofiya: istoriya, metodologiya, zhizn' [Russian philosophy: history, methodology, life], eds. G. Alyaev, T. Sukhodub, Poltava: ASMI, 2011.

Ukrayins'kyy chasopys rosіys'koyi fіlosofіyi. Vіsnyk tovarystva rosіys'koyi fіlo¬so¬fіyi pry Ukrayins'komu fіlosofs'komu fondі [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so¬phi¬cal foundation], No. 1: Metamorfozy svobody: spadshchyna Berdyaeva u suchasnomu dyskursі (do 125-rіchchya z dnya narodzhennya M. O. Berdyaeva) [Metamorphoses of freedom: Berdyaev’s heritage in the modern discourse (to the 125th anniversary of the birth of N. A. Berdyaev)], Kiev: PARAPAN, 2003.

Ukrayins'kyy chasopys rosіys'koyi fіlosofіyi. Vіsnyk tovarystva rosіys'koyi fіlo¬so¬fіyi pry Ukrayins'komu fіlosofs'komu fondі [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so¬phi¬cal foundation], No. 4: Fіlosofіya prava v Rosіyi: Vіtchyznyana vіyna 1812 roku і rozvytok rosіys'koyi polіtychnoyi kul'tury [Philosophy of law in Russia: the Patriotic War of 1812 and the development of Russian political culture], Kiev: DAKKKіM, 2006.

Ukrayins'kyy chasopys rosіys'koyi fіlosofіyi. Vіsnyk tovarystva rosіys'koyi fіlo¬so¬fіyi pry Ukrayins'komu fіlosofs'komu fondі [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so¬phi¬cal foundation], No. 7: Kolіzіyi syntezu fіlosofіyi і relіgіyi v іstorіyi vіtchyznyanoyi fіlo¬so¬fіyi (do 180-rіchchya Pamfіla Yurkevycha ta 130-rіchchya Semena Franka) [Col¬li¬sions of the synthesis of philosophy and religion in the history of the national phi¬lo¬sophy (to the 180th anniversary of Pamfil Yurkevich and the 130th anniversary of Semyon Frank], Poltava: ASMІ, 2007.

Ukrayins'kyy chasopys rosіys'koyi fіlosofіyi. Vіsnyk tovarystva rosіys'koyi fіlo¬so¬fіyi pry Ukrayins'komu fіlosofs'komu fondі [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so¬phi¬cal foundation], No. 11: Іstorіya fіlosofії u vіtchiznyanіy dukhovnіy kul'turі [History of philosophy in the national spiritual culture], eds. G. Alyaev, T. Sukhodub, Poltava: ASMІ, 2014.

Ukrayins'kyy chasopys rosіys'koyi fіlosofіyi. Vіsnyk tovarystva rosіys'koyi fіlo¬so¬fіyi pry Ukrayins'komu fіlosofs'komu fondі [Ukrainian journal of Russian phi¬lo¬sophy. Bulletin of the Society of Russian philosophy at the Ukrainian philo¬so¬phi¬cal foundation], No. 12: Іstorіya fіlosofії u vіtchiznyanіy dukhovnіy kul'turі [History of philosophy in the national spiritual culture], eds. G. Alyaev, T. Sukhodub, Poltava: ASMІ, 2016.

Frank, S.L. [The spiritual origins of the Russian revolution], in Vestnik Russkoy khristianskoy gumanitarnoy akademii [Bul¬le¬tin of the Russian Christian Academy of the Humanities], 2018, No. 2, vol. 19.

Published
2018-12-31
How to Cite
Suhodub, T. (2018). Quiet power of thinking (reflections on the fate of the historian of philosophy in the modern world). Philosophical Polylogue, (2), 85-97. Retrieved from http://polylogue.jourssa.ru/index.php/polylogue/article/view/35
Section
EVENTS